Oct 10 2008
The importance of hedges
You will make mistakes as an investor…
1. It’s nearly impossible to time the market. Just read my blog and you’ll see.
2. People are prone to buying high and selling low. It’s human nature.
3. If it goes your way, you get happy and get out too early.
4. If it goes against you, you remain in denial and stay in the position.
The best thing you can do is be comfortable with your portfolio allocation. Trying to trade in a long term account will lead to disasterous results and that’s why I don’t do it. Less than a month ago, my long term account had the following breakdown…
14.1% Vanguard Treasury Money Market Fund (VMPXX)
26.0% Vanguard Inflation Protected Securities (VIPSX)
42.1% Merk Hard Currency Fund (MERKX)
17.5% Prudent Bear Fund (BEARX)
Since then, a tiny bit of cash has come into VMPXX, my inflation protected securities got screwed hard because we are in a deflationary credit collapse, and my currency fund got smashed a little more. MERKX and VIPSX are my inflation hedges while VMPXX and BEARX are my deflation plays. Now my allocation is as follows…
17.8% Vanguard Treasury Money Market Fund (VMPXX)
24.5% Vanguard Inflation Protected Securities (VIPSX)
40.3% Merk Hard Currency Fund (MERKX)
21.0% Prudent Bear Fund (BEARX)
7.2% rise in allocation for my deflation plays, 7.2% drop in allocation for my inflation hedges. Total value of long term account is roughly unchanged and in a deflationary environment, that’s a net win. Why not go all in with deflation plays? Because I could be wrong. Why not go all in with inflation hedges? Because I don’t think we will have massive inflation.
I do believe that VIPSX and MERKX will fall much further and that BEARX will continue roaring higher. However, I am not touching anything in my long term account. Why not? Again, because I could be wrong. As long as I am properly hedged, I’m fine. Having my long term account stay relatively flat while people’s 401ks and IRAs are getting smashed means I have nothing to complain about.
The classical hedge is to buy both stocks and bonds but as you know, I hate stocks and it’s a real challenge to diversify without stocks. If you want to diversify with stocks, all you need to do is buy an index fund. If you want to diversify outside of stocks, it is a challenge. Even outside of stocks, there really is no safe place for your money.
1. Leave it in a bank? FDIC insurance is worthless. Trust me on this one.
2. Safe low yielding T-bills. Inflation will eat you alive.
3. Long bonds. Already overbought, and if the foreigners dump our bonds, you don’t want to be here. Also, it wasn’t the 1929 stock market crash that brought on the Great Depression, it was the 1931 bond market crash.
4. Inflation protected securites. Pointless in deflation. Even during times of inflation, it’s stupid because the government will understate inflation.
5. Foreign currencies. We are screwed, the rest of the world is screwed worse. Do you really want to hold this crap?
6. 5 year CDs. No access to money for 5 years. If we get a deflationary collapse, then you will score big, that is, if the FDIC actually backs you up and if you really can survive without that cash in deflationary collapse.
7. Gold. Useless in deflation. If gold shoots the moon, watch the government step in a seize it, instantly making it worthless.
8. Oil futures. Bad in deflation. If oil shoots the moon, an alternative energy source will keep the price of oil in check. An oil spike also results in a recession, instantly screwing over the demand for oil.
This totally sucks man.
